Best approval odds in Wisconsin (2025)

Lenders that say no least often, measured on applications they actually decided. Withdrawn and incomplete files are excluded so the figure reflects the lender, not the applicant.

227kApplications in WI
16.4%State decision denial rate
6.63%State median rate
Top-rated mortgage lenders Best approval odds Lowest median interest rates Largest mortgage lenders by volume Top FHA lenders Top VA lenders Top refinance lenders Top home equity lenders
Wisconsin ▾
#LenderGradeDecision denial rateApplicationsDenial rateMedian rate
1 Thompson Kane & CompanyMadison, WI A 1.7% 921 0.8% 6.75%
2 The Bank of New GlarusNew Glarus, A 1.2% 498 1.0% 6.63%
3 A + Mortgage ServicesMuskego, WI A 1.5% 848 1.4% 6.63%
4 Waterstone MortgageBrookfield, WI C 4.7% 469 1.7% 6.63%
5 Ixonia BankIxonia, WI C 4.7% 1,676 2.2% 6.75%
6 Nations LendingIndependence, OH B 6.2% 1,065 2.8% 6.63%
7 Ark-La-Tex Financial Services, LLC.Plano, TX A 3.4% 345 2.9% 6.50%
8 Coastal Community BankEverett, WA C 3.0% 1,486 2.5% 10.99%
9 PCM Credit UnionGreen Bay, WI A 3.2% 485 3.1% 5.99%
10 CO-OP Credit UnionBlack River Falls, WI B 3.3% 413 3.2% 6.55%
11 Forward BankMarshfield, WI A 4.2% 447 3.8% 7.00%
12 Westby Co-op Credit UnionWestby, B 4.0% 506 3.2% 7.13%
13 FOX COMMUNITIES Credit UnionAppleton, WI A 4.0% 3,040 3.9% 6.49%
14 Nicolet National BankGreen Bay, WI A 4.5% 2,608 4.0% 7.25%
15 Movement MortgageLancaster, SC A 4.8% 530 3.8% 6.75%
16 Bank Five NineOconomowoc, WI A 4.8% 1,584 4.0% 6.50%
17 Guild MortgageSan Diego, CA A 4.7% 2,875 4.0% 6.63%
18 CMG MortgageSan Ramon, CA A 5.6% 876 3.9% 6.75%
19 Fairway Independent MortgageMadison, WI B 6.1% 3,754 4.1% 6.63%
20 Barrington Bank & Trust CompanyBarrington, IL C 9.1% 1,492 4.4% 6.49%
21 First Colony MortgageOrem, UT A 5.6% 1,235 4.4% 6.50%
22 Home State BankCrystal Lake, IL B 5.2% 356 5.3% 6.43%
23 Wisconsin MortgageBrookfield, WI B 6.3% 502 5.2% 6.50%
24 ALTRA Federal Credit UnionOnalaska, WI B 9.3% 1,747 5.8% 6.66%
25 Crosscountry MortgageCleveland, OH B 5.7% 1,553 4.8% 6.75%
26 Great Midwest Bank, S.S.B.Brookfield, WI B 6.5% 492 5.7% 6.75%
27 Prosperity Home MortgageFairfax, VA A 7.8% 1,007 5.7% 6.38%
28 Horicon BankHoricon, WI B 7.2% 527 6.3% 6.75%
29 One Community BankOregon, WI B 7.1% 550 6.6% 7.25%
30 Union Home MortgageStrongsville, OH B 6.7% 801 6.1% 6.63%
31 Lake Ridge BankMiddleton, WI A 7.5% 886 6.6% 5.49%
32 Kohler Credit UnionSheboygan, WI B 9.0% 902 6.4% 7.00%
33 ServionNew Brighton, MN B 6.7% 394 6.4% 6.50%
34 Guaranteed RateChicago, IL B 9.2% 1,797 5.4% 6.53%
35 CAPITAL Credit UnionGreen Bay, WI A 7.7% 2,892 6.5% 6.25%
36 The Equitable Bank, S.S.B.Wauwatosa, WI B 7.6% 340 6.8% 6.38%
37 Johnson Financial GroupRacine, WI A 7.8% 3,702 7.4% 6.75%
38 Waukesha State BankWaukesha, WI B 7.8% 915 7.1% 6.75%
39 Bell BankFargo, ND A 7.1% 1,313 6.6% 6.50%
40 Community FirstNeenah, WI A 8.0% 4,368 6.9% 5.49%
41 Compeer Financial, FlcaPrairie Du Sac, WI C 10.6% 869 7.6% 7.13%
42 Covantage Credit UnionAntigo, WI B 10.2% 4,581 7.7% 6.50%
43 Bank FirstManitowoc, WI A 9.2% 2,184 8.6% 6.88%
44 The Park BankMadison, WI B 9.1% 606 7.9% 6.50%
45 American Pacific MortgageRoseville, CA C 10.3% 998 7.6% 6.63%
46 Verve, a Credit UnionOshkosh, WI B 10.2% 926 8.1% 6.50%
47 Heartland Credit Union (Madison)Madison, WI B 10.7% 652 7.8% 6.99%
48 Cardinal Financial Company, Limited PartnershipCharlotte, NC B 10.8% 619 10.3% 6.75%
49 Royal Credit UnionEau Claire, WI B 11.4% 3,788 9.6% 6.75%
50 Blackhawk Community Credit UnionJanesville, WI B 12.3% 774 9.8% 7.50%

How this list is built

Ordered by decision denial rate: denied ÷ (originated + approved-not-accepted + denied). Lenders must have decided at least 300 applications in the state. All figures come from the lenders' own HMDA filings. Full methodology.